Is Helping Always Helpful?


Poziom: B1+/B2

Pomaganie, wolontariat i zdrowie psychiczne – czy pomoc zawsze pomaga? Zakręć kołem i porozmawiaj.

Pełna lekcja Let’s Talk: Help – w sklepie

Quote to Spark Discussion

  • Do you agree with Anne Frank that no one has ever become poor by giving?
  • Can you think of situations where giving too much might be a problem?
  • Is generosity always a good thing?

General Questions About Helping Others

  • When was the last time you helped someone? What did you do?
  • Do you find it easy or difficult to ask for help? Why?
  • What are some small ways people can help others in daily life?
  • Do you prefer helping a stranger or someone you know? Why?
  • What motivates people to help others?

Charity and Volunteering

  • Have you ever donated money or volunteered for a cause? What was it?
  • Would you rather give money or your time to help others? Why?
  • What types of charities do you trust the most (e.g. animal shelters, children’s organisations)?
  • Should students be encouraged to do volunteer work? Why or why not?
  • What are some popular charity events in your country?

Helping Locally vs. Globally

  • Is it more important to help people in your own country or in poorer countries? Why?
  • How can we know which charity organisations are really effective?
  • Do you think celebrities help causes because they care or for publicity?
  • Should wealthier countries do more to help refugees or developing nations?
  • Can social media campaigns like fundraising challenges make a real difference?

Controversial Questions

  • Should people be forced (e.g. by school or work) to do charity work?
  • Is giving money to homeless people helpful or harmful in the long term?
  • Should rich people be required to donate a portion of their income to charity?
  • Do charities sometimes do more harm than good by creating dependency?
  • Is it fair to judge people who don’t donate or volunteer?

Mental Health and Helping Others

  • What does 'mental health’ mean to you?
  • How can friends or family support someone who is going through a hard time mentally?
  • What are some signs that a person might need help with their mental health?
  • Is talking to a psychologist or therapist common in your culture? Why or why not?
  • What can schools or workplaces do to support mental well-being?

Mental Strength and Resilience

  • What does it mean to be 'mentally strong’?
  • Do you think mental strength can be learned, or is it something we are born with?
  • Can difficult life experiences make a person stronger? In what ways?
  • How do you personally handle stress or emotional challenges?
  • Do you think people today are more fragile than in the past? Why or why not?

Controversial & Debate-Oriented Questions

  • Do some people use 'mental health’ as an excuse to avoid responsibility?
  • Is being mentally strong a choice, or is it something outside of our control?
  • Can too much support and empathy make people dependent or less resilient?
  • Should people be expected to 'tough it out’ sometimes, or is that a harmful idea?

Moral & Reflective Questions

  • If a friend told you they were feeling hopeless or deeply sad, what would you say or do?
  • Do you think society still judges people with mental illnesses? In what ways?
  • What do you think is harder: asking for help or helping someone who doesn’t want it?
  • Can social media be a source of support for mental health, or does it do more harm?

Quote to Spark Deeper Thought

  • Do you agree that sometimes asking for help is the bravest move you can make?
  • Why do many people find it difficult to ask for help?
  • Does society reward independence more than vulnerability?